Abby’s Origin Story: From Shadowy Character on Season 2 to Centerpiece Spotlight on Season 3 of TLOU
Abby (Kaitlyn Dever) exploded into The Last of Us Season 2 during Episode 2, swinging a hammer that would change the series forever: Joel’s death was brutal, personal, and instantly divisive. Initially portrayed as the villain, Abby’s role unraveled over the season, especially in the finale “Convergence,” which painted her as a deeply loyal soldier of the Washington Liberation Front (WLF), burdened by grief and trying to survive a world that keeps punishing her.
The showrunners made a bold move by ending Season 2 with a full pivot to Abby’s perspective — mirroring the controversial structure of the game — and forcing audiences to see her side of the story. As Decider put it, this shift asked viewers “to empathize with a figure they once viewed as villainous.”
Fan Fallout: Love, Loathe, and Everything In-Between
Season 2’s divergence from the beloved Ellie-and-Joel dynamic ignited a firestorm online. Rotten Tomatoes user scores dropped from 61% after Episode 1 to 39% by Episode 6, driven by backlash over Joel’s shocking exit and Abby’s complex but divisive arc.
Some fans praised Kaitlyn Dever’s raw, emotionally charged performance, while others dragged the show for what they called a “woke” rewrite and pointed out Abby’s physical difference from her video game counterpart, especially vocal on forums and review threads.
Social-Media Buzz
On X (formerly Twitter), hashtags like #AbbyAndUs and #TLOU2 trended for days as fans debated Abby’s morality, motivations, and parallels to Ellie. Some celebrated the narrative risk; others simply missed Joel.
Over on TikTok, @dd.dollaz’s viral clip joking about Abby’s single line in Episode 2 racked up over 19K likes, while videos under hashtags like #AbbyBruised and #TLOUSeason2 have gathered millions of views. Fan edits, emotional scene breakdowns, and arguments over who’s the “real villain” of Season 2 have kept engagement sky-high.
Looking Ahead: Abby’s Lead in Season 3
The showrunners aren’t backing down. At HBO’s For Your Consideration panel — held for Emmy voters — co-creator Neil Druckmann confirmed that Season 3 will center on Abby, with Kaitlyn Dever returning in the lead role. Druckmann called it “more of a water season than a fire season,” hinting at swampy environments, rain-soaked ruins, and more physical/emotional survival.
As reported by WinterIsComing.net and sourced via The Hollywood Reporter, Druckmann said:
“I was sure they wouldn’t let us… but they’ve leaned into what makes the story special.”
This Season 3 narrative is now in active development, though filming won’t begin until after Dever finishes her current slate — likely not until 2026.
While some fans are thrilled to see Abby’s deeper layers explored, others remain cautious after the emotional whiplash of Season 2. But one thing’s clear: love her or hate her, Abby has taken center stage — and The Last of Us will never be the same again.
Discover more from HIGHMOORE
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.